I recently purchased elf's creme eyeliner. I'm in love. it looks like liquid when applied but doesn't end up looking like i have black eyeshadow on. It doesn't budge all day. The true test was wearing it to work (salon) with blow dryers going, hot humidity and being on your feet all day. sign up for they're email list because they're sales are out of this planet. It's already totally affordable but who doesn't love buy one get one 50% off or free shipping?? Not to mention they donate to the Japan relief. Best $3 dollars i ever spent. That's right you can find that in your couch cushion.
I also purchased the eyeshadow primer and it is primo as well. They go together like peas and carrots.